Navigating Job Offer Decisions & Dilemmas

What happens when you get a job offer and you’re not 100% sure?  Here are 3 scenarios you might find yourself in.

1. You Get A Job Offer but Hoping For An Offer From a Different Company

Receiving a job offer while you're waiting for a potentially better one can put you in a challenging position. Here's what you can do to handle this situation professionally.

Assess the Timeframe: If you have a deadline to respond to the current offer, evaluate if it aligns with when you expect to hear back from the other opportunity. If the timelines don't align, consider negotiating an extension with the current offer's employer. Be transparent with the employer who made the offer. Politely ask for additional time to consider the offer, mentioning your genuine interest in the role and the company. Assure them of your commitment to making an informed decision.

Continue Pursuing Other Opportunities: Keep in touch with the employer of the potential better offer. Politely inquire about their decision-making timeline. Express your enthusiasm for the role without undermining your interest in the current offer.

Consider Your Priorities: Evaluate the pros and cons of both opportunities. Consider factors like company culture, growth potential, compensation, benefits, and alignment with your career goals. Make a decision based on your priorities and what matters most to you.

NOTE: Keep in mind you need to do what’s best for you. There are no guarantees and you can only make an informed decision with what you’re given.

2. You Get a Better Offer After You Accepted Another Job Offer

Finding yourself in this situation can be uncomfortable, but it's crucial to handle it professionally and respectfully to all parties involved.

Review the Accepted Offer's Terms: Carefully examine the terms of the accepted offer, including any clauses related to reneging on the agreement. This will help you understand the potential consequences of withdrawing your acceptance.

Communicate Promptly: Reach out to the employer who extended the initial offer as soon as possible. Express your gratitude for the opportunity and professionalism while explaining that unforeseen circumstances have arisen, leading you to reconsider your decision. Offer a sincere apology for any inconvenience caused by your decision to decline the accepted offer. Be honest about the reasons behind your change of heart, citing the compelling aspects of the new offer or how it aligns better with your career goals.

Accept Responsibility: Acknowledge the impact of your decision on the employer and emphasize your desire to maintain a positive relationship. Ensure your communication is polite, professional, and focused on your personal career growth.

NOTE: The employer could potentially put you on their blacklist. This might prevent any future opportunities in the company. But don’t let this potential deter you from making the best decision for you.

3. You Want to Stay in Your Current Company After Getting a Job Offer

If you receive an external job offer but decide to stay with your current employer, handling the situation with professionalism and honesty is essential.

Evaluate Your Decision: Reflect on why you initially considered leaving. Assess if the factors that led you to explore other opportunities can be addressed within your current role or company.  If there were specific reasons driving your job search, consider discussing them with your current employer in a constructive manner. Seek ways to address any concerns or improve your current situation to avoid similar issues in the future.

Communicate Graciously: Inform the company that extended the job offer about your decision to decline, expressing your appreciation for the offer and the consideration given to you. Be honest about your decision to stay, highlighting your continued commitment to your current role and the company.

Maintain Professionalism: Regardless of your decision, maintain professionalism throughout the process. Ensure your communication is respectful and that you express gratitude for the opportunities presented to you.

NOTE: You don’t have to accept any offers presented to you if they do not align with your priorities. The process of finding employment and receiving offers is reciprocal, benefiting both parties, not solely advantageous to the employer.

In any of these scenarios, being respectful, honest, and professional in your communication is key. Prioritize your own career goals while also considering the impact of your decisions on the involved parties.

Still unsure what’s the best decision for you.  Schedule a call and let’s chat.

Related content:
Best decision making tool
Small Goals, Big Wins
Uncover Hidden Stress

Stay connected